Friday

No Break-Up

Yesterday, I read through the comments on the previous post. The concept that resonated the most was “Wait and see what happens when the ex-girlfriend moves here.” I am a very wait and see sort of girl. It’s the only rational course of behavior. Otherwise you’re just dealing with make-believe and paranoia. I truly believe that patience is the key to a healthy relationship.

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

The comments that resonated the most were "Dump Re-Boyfriend," because seriously, I cannot walk around with a stomachache for months, living on borrowed relationship time and trying not to vomit. I decided to take a break from Re-Boyfriend and give him all the ex-girlfriend loving time he needed. Since the last argument had gone so hysterically wrong with the crying and the yelling (yes, that would have been me) I decided that I should be in a public place this time and, more importantly, not drunk.

Things started to go awry when I met my mother for dinner. We had two glasses of wine. Things went further awry when my mother advised me to “pretend” break-up with him, just to see what he would do. She likes to study Zen Buddhism, meditate and talk about the meaning of life, but when it comes to practical matters her advice is never guided by a higher meaning and in fact shows a blatant disregard for “doing the right thing.”

CB: I don’t think that’s, like, mature.
Mom (with dismissive hand motion): Whatever.

Then Re-Boyfriend called and said he had to stay in his apartment to open the door for a keyless roommate.

Fine. Maybe the “not drunk” and the “in a public place” conditions had been thwarted but I would stick to the truly important thing—the speech.

“I think we should take a break while your ex is here. You can figure things out and then, a few months later, we can talk about getting back together. I just don’t want to be your girlfriend while you figure out how to be, or if you can be, friends with your ex.”

I was so rational. It was beautiful. I didn’t even feel like I might cry.

“No.”

“Excuse me?”

“No. I can't let you do that.”

"Is this like a George Costanza thing?"

"We are not breaking up."

“I didn’t say that, I said ‘take a break’.”

“No.”

We had reached an impasse.

The situation was resolved when Re-Boyfriend began to look panicky and said he wouldn’t see the ex at all, ever, if that was what I wanted. (Though he did add, "I just feel really mean.")

As soon as he said that, I felt a lot better, benevolent even. Would it really be so bad if he saw her once in a great while?

Then I thought I might have been, unwittingly, a little manipulative.

Then I thought I might be a lot closer to the stereotypical crazy female than I would like to believe.

Then I thought, “Whatever.”

41 comments:

C.S. said...

Good work.

Wear the shirt tonight to celebrate.

N said...

CB~

I am SOOOO relieved and happy for you. Also, Re-Boyfriend's stock just went way, way up.

Oh, and the speech~ very impressive. You are one classy lady!!!

Let me just say it again, as I have practically had a stomach ache for you the last couple of days~ I am so very happy for you both. Good luck!

Emily and Chey said...

okay, few things first. as a company bitch myself, with oodles of time to spend pretending to work, i read all the archives for your blog all day wednesday at the office. i too have faxed things the wrongside up and then accused people of having broken fax machines. i too have competed with a perky, and i too have experienced the weird-lunch-with-boss-to-show-appreciation. awkward! needless to say, your blog is freaking awesome. as for re-boyfriend, is it okay to say i had a feeling he would say that all along? you are obviously the most important person to him, what with all the marriage banter he throws around to his friends and co-workers, and also all the weird presents. as a cb with my own boyfriend issues, trust me when i say that you were not being manipulative. you were taking care of you and attempting to protect yourself from being hurt by a potentially hurtful sitatuion. it just so happens re-boyfriend loves you so much he's willing to not-hurt-you too. freaking awesome.

ps said...

i love it.

Shoe-shine boy said...

shitcan reboyfriend. overall he doesn't seem like a good for ye anyhow. cut to the chase.

Broady said...

Well done. You need to take care of yourself and do things on your terms. He sounds like a charming bastard, I know from experience the dangers of that type!
Good luck, can't wait to read about the progress. Also, your mom is hilarious. More about her, please.

DevilsHeaven said...

I feel like Ross and Rachel have been brought to life again! "Taking a break" has a whole new meaning because of them. Anyway, I think you handled it well, because I know I would have lost it the minute my lips parted to start the speech.

One thing to all the females, you need to read "He's Just Not That Into You." by Greg Barrett. It will change your dating life, CHANGE IT I tell you!!!!!
Don't Waste the Pretty!!!!!!!!!

mere said...

my stomach feels better now, too. it's such a nice surprise when they do the right thing!

Golightly said...

LOVES it! Way to go.

Am loving mom's advice: “pretend” break-up...LMAO, how many times I've done that just to manipulate as well. Us, women, we are all crazy like that but it's the boys that make us that way!

Somebody's Proncess said...

CB--way to go. You're his girlfriend now, and how he feels about you is way more important than being "mean" to her.

I salute you.

STAG said...

Hey, there is nothing wrong with the truth.

Gaijinity said...

"Do the right thing"??? Are you high? He just got played big time. Snaps to you, CB, credit where credit's due, but karma's a bitch, friend.

ryan said...

Do you have evil ex-girlfriend's number? She sounds hot & rich. I will date her and then everyone wins.

GenuineSmiles said...

good job. not sure if you did it as a pretend or for real, but good job. not only did you get him to say he won't see her, you've just found out how much he really cares for you.

i agree w/the above...wear the t-shirt tonight for him. add pigtails and knee socks...he'll freak out... :)

Bindress said...

Funny, even rebf's room mate doesnt have a key? Hummmm, is rebf a control freak or something!
Well done CB. Sometimes just the mere thought of a break up can bring our other half back to reality. And realise much can be lost by not keeping temptation way away.
Yes, more about mom please!

-LGirl- said...

You are Soooooo gonna marry this fella!

Nicole said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Nicole said...

You were a little manipulative and you are most definitely a stereotypical crazy female. Might I suggest using the whatever thing on the ex-girlfriend situation instead of freaking out about it.

Shoe-shine boy said...

-LGirl- said, "You are Soooooo gonna marry this fella!"

Ah. To be 24 again...

Drunken Master said...

Your inadvertant manipulation does seem rather Lady Macbeth-ish.

Lara said...

Alright, move in with the dude already!

Malaika said...

cool beans chick...

strange bird said...

I know ultimatums are supposed to be a bad thing and all, and usually I agree, but since you didn't actually give him one you are totally in the clear ;).

Good for him for realizing what was more important to him (and that being you)!

Ki Two said...

Oh, that was just lovely! Great circular post, very nice. *claps*

beingmccrary said...

The problem was that he felt he was not in control of his life when you were crying and yelling at him not to see the exgirlfriend. Now...you've just made him feel in complete control of his life...even though it's clear who is in control here.

Well done.

Anostica said...

I'm glad how things unfolded for you, and how things are turning out. However I'm going to put in some words of caution..not trying to be a devils advocate or anything.

Did you ever wonder if he just said he won't the ex because you kept talking about...what if he said it to make us woman just shut up? I hope it's because he loves you and says he doesn't want to see her if you dislike it..and it's not to make you quiet. If the latter is the case, I'd be worried, as I'm sure he'll see her behind your back.

I still think it would have been better to have waited and seen how things unfolded. Many a times you meet the girl and think, hahaha I'm so much better than that. And the whole storm/psycho drama we made up in our heads goes away. In any case, an ultimatum is/was a good idea. I'd be veary (sp) of using it too much though, however, because there might come a time that you've been giving soo many ultimatums that he may get fed up and leave...

again just some thoughts..

the real me is completely happy for you!! and I hope everything works out :)

Bindress said...

You might end up being friends with exgf. She maybe really cool. You never know. I think its a good thing to have a lot of friends. I live in the middle of no where and have not had the chance to meet new people. Boo hoo!

angelsarentfree said...

LOVE how bindress managed to make her comment all about her.
Props to you and of course it was manipulative, but women can't help but be. God gave men brute strength and woman the ability to manipulate. Its just how He evened the playing field. So basically, we can't help it, its innate.

Dana said...

See? Your mom's advice kind of worked, didn't it??? I hate when my mom is right. It infuriates me.

happyicecream said...

Highly manipulative, I think.

How would you, or any of the commenters to this post, feel if re-bf threw hysterical fits and forced you to not see a good male friend of yours?

It is not, an cannot, ever be right to dictate to someone who their friends may or may not be. If the solution to your inability to cope with your own insecurity is to strangle his social life at will, you are doomed. He will ultimately resent you as you twist his life into being what you want, not what he wants.

Just because you see his ex as a threat does not mean that she is. If you are unable to keep your own boyfriend interested in you, then your relationship is far more tenuous than you think. She may be after him still, but that does not mean that his is interested or will respond. It takes two, remember? Though perhaps you don't know that - you're acting as if in your relationship there is only one: yourself.

Cat said...

G'day,
I'm with Sunanda on this one.
You could temporarily change your name to ICB, Insecure Company Bitch.
This one's gonna come round and bite you on the bum!
Take something away from someone, and they will find it irresistable.

Random Musings Of My Life said...

WOAH Happy ICE cream feels really strongley about that..
Lol
We are women we are crazy
"whatever"
I should stop by once and tell you about the fit I through when I was dating (now husband) and my BEST FRIEND who knew him 4 years before I did kissed him on the mouth (she kisses EVERYONE on the mouth) FRIGGIN HELL THAT WAS FUNNY>
I think beer trowing and crying in public were part of it as well

down_not_out said...

So, give it a while and see how it goes. There's nothing wrong with a healthy relationship with an ex. You won't know how things will go until they get going.

Several years ago I asked a woman, married 20+ years, how she made things work and how she managed to be so happy. She said, "Well. Here's the trick: Hold on tight and hope for the best."

My mother, now married 20 years, said it took a good ten before she realized she was happy and fifteen before she figured out she couldn't imagine living any other way.

Life and love are tough. Hang on tight and hope for the best. Give it time and look back, with new perspective, and hopefully you'll see all is well.

Good luck.

Jess said...

I hate to be one of those people that randomly post things like, "Yeah for you!" or "Props my friend!" but before this particular post I read your blog more for fun than anything else. But your situation with ReBoyfriend always seemed to be a little too familiar.
And then he just said, "No" to your break suggestion and I was like, "Holy shit! Do I know you? Are you me? Are we dating the same fucking guy?!"
My own ReBoyfriend has done the break-veto to me about a dozen times. I hate that shit.
Doesn't it make you just want to smack them and be like, "Hey! Don't you just veto me! I get a say too!"
If I didn't have a thing for penises, I'd become a lesbian.

Shoe-shine boy said...

no way reboyfriend gave up so easy. he'll just bide his time until you go away and then he'lll have an innocent dinner with ExGF. Which even if it is innocent will wreak havoc on you (and by proxy, us).

ReBF has got to go.

Bindress said...

Sorry Angel. Didnt mean to do that.

Old Lady said...

Everything you have gone through, expressed and felt is normal reaction. The words you used to RBF were well thought out and adult. His reaction was as well. You both have expressed honest feeling to each other and that is a big step in any relationship. Communication is and always will be the key. In the end you will always have to go with your heart, what you can live with and what is best for you

Jackass Jenn said...

Then Re-Boyfriend called and said he had to stay in his apartment to open the door for a keyless roommate.

Regardless of what the topic may or may not have been -plotting break-up, feaux break-up, or even deciding where to meet you later after your dinner with mom - my question is why when he calls you to say he has to stay for keyless roomie, why didn't you ask him why he can't let roomie stand on stoop and dodge dodgy propositions? All in good fun of course, but c'MON.

Currin Girl said...

Where'd my comment go?

Anna said...

You're awesome

strange bird said...

Now that I've read all of your archives, I have reassessed my earlier statement: he's going to see her anyway. Just without your knowledge. And he's probably eventually going to sleep with her again.

Really, he sounds like a total shitface.

But good luck with that.